A Problem in Three Squares: What Is This About?
A Mathematical Droodle
Explanation
Copyright © 1996-2009 Alexander Bogomolny
An interesting fact holds in a configuration of three equal squares placed side by side. If the lines drawn as shown then BDC + BFC = BEC. There are many proofs of this result. These are so simple, the problem has been included in many a puzzle book.
First note that BEC = 45o. The task is then to show that BDC + BFC = 45o. Let's introduce a = BDC and b = BFC. We are to prove that a + b = 45o.
Proof 1
Add another row of squares below the given three. BKD is isosceles (BK = DK) and, in addition, K = 90o. Therefore, BDK = 45o. However, since triangles DEK and FCB are equal, we also have KDE = b.
Proof 2
Now with some trigonometry (arctan = tan-1),
| |
| a + b | = arctan(1/3) + arctan(1/2) |
| | = arctan((1/3 + 1/2)/(1 - 1/3·1/2)) |
| | = arctan(1), |
|
where I used the standard formula for the tangent of a sum
| | tan(a + b) = (tan(a) + tan(b))/(1 - tan(a)·tan(b)). |
Since arctan(1) = 45o, a + b = 45o.
Proof 3
Triangles BDE and FEB are similar. Indeed, assuming the side of the square equals 1, then
| |
| DE = 2, | BE = 2, | DE/BE = 2, |
BE = 2, | EF = 1, | BE/EF = 2, |
BD = 10, | BF = 5, | BD/BF = 2, |
|
which implies that BDC = FBE = a. Finally, the exterior angle BEC of FEB, equals the sum of the opposite interior angles, i.e., a + b.
References
- B. Richardson, Three Squares Theorem, in The Changing Shape of Geometry, edited by C. Pritchard, Cambridge University Press, 2003
Copyright © 1996-2009 Alexander Bogomolny
|