There are really impossible things...

Who says nothing is impossible? Some people do it every day!

Alfred E. Neuman

The fact that there are impossible things is hardly surprising. It's obvious (?) one can't draw a straight line with a compass. We already saw some less trivial examples. For example, I can't create a slider device that would allow switching between all slider puzzles available at this site. Such a device would constitute a mega-puzzle to which a switch will have to be provided, which in turn would create another mega-mega-puzzle and so on ad infinitum. Selfreferences allow for questions that could not be logically answered.

However, if you think that the only impossible things are trivial and those that depend on some kind of math trickery, think twice. There are really impossible things. There are a few known yet from antiquity that were attempted by dozens (and probably more) for thousands years until their impossibility has been revealed in recent times.

  1. A good half of all starting positions in the Fifteen puzzle are unsolvable.
  2. Constructing a triangle from its angle bisectors is in general impossible
  3. Creating a machine that would tell for every statement whether it's true or false.
  4. Deriving Euclid's fifth postulate from the other four.
  5. Doubling a cube
  6. Finding the center of a given circle with the straightedge alone
  7. An Impossible Frame
  8. An Impossible Fork
  9. An Impossible Page
  10. Impossible to optimize the ratio Area/Price by a combination of two pizzas of different sizes.
  11. Moving pegs five places in one direction
  12. Representing 2 as a rational fraction p/q.
  13. Solving the general quintic equation in radicals.
  14. Squaring a circle
  15. Structural Constellation
  16. Trisecting an angle (in general)
  17. Emptying Prisons with Simple Shapes
  18. It is impossible to find four consecutive integers whose product is a square.

Let me remark that with so many (simple) things impossible some possible things appear nothing less than surprising. There are even those that appear at first sight impossible, but can be easily made even from paper with very little effort.

There is a fine logical puzzle about two identical twins. Well, they were not quite identical, but appeared to give identical answers to identical questions. Is it possible to devise a sequence of questions that require yes/no answers so that, as a result, one would tell one brother from the other? Here too, that which seems impossible proves to be possible after all.

Needless to say, one should not try to do anything impossible. But more than that, one is morally obligated not to do anything impossible.


Related material
Read more...

  • An Impossible Frame
  • An Impossible Fork
  • Structural Constellation
  • Squaring a circle
  • Trisecting an angle (in general)
  • Doubling a cube
  • A puzzle of identical twins
  • Geometric construction with the straightedge alone
  • |Contact| |Front page| |Contents| |Did you know?|

    Copyright © 1996-2017 Alexander Bogomolny

     62596981

    Search by google: