Dao's Variant of Thebault's First Problem

What Might This Be About?


Similarly oriented squares are constructed on the sides of a parallelogram. The sides of the parallelogram are extended to intersect the lines joining the centers of the squares, as shown:

Dao's Variant of Thebault's First Problem - problem

Prove that the points of the intersection form a square.

Proof 1

This problem is obviously related to Thébault's Problem 1. The vertices of Thébault's square lie on the lines of the centers of the constructed squares and so do the vertices of the alleged square in the present problem. Because of this and due to the central symmetry inherent in the problem, the shape in question is a rhombus. It then suffices to show that its diagonals are equal. The following diagram sheds extra light on the configuration by emphasizing two groups of equal angles. The proof that this is indeed so is left as an exercise.

Dao's Variant of Thebault's First Problem - solution, angles

The proof itself is illustrated by the diagram below. Trigonometry is the main tool, especially the Law of Sines.

Dao's Variant of Thebault's First Problem - solution

Thus we have that



and have to show that



In $\Delta NYW,$ $\displaystyle x=\frac{a\sin\beta}{\cos\alpha}.$ In $\Delta XYW,$ $XY=x\tan (90^{\circ}-\alpha )$ such that


In $\Delta MUY,$ $y=\displaystyle\frac{b\sin\beta}{\sin (\alpha+\beta )}.$ In $\Delta UYZ,$ $YZ=y\tan (\alpha +\beta ),$ i.e.,

$YZ=\displaystyle\frac{b\sin\beta}{\sin (\alpha+\beta )}\cdot\frac{\sin (\alpha+\beta )}{\cos (\alpha+\beta )}=\frac{b\sin\beta}{\cos (\alpha+\beta)}.$

In $\Delta MX'Y,$ $X'Y=\displaystyle\frac{b\cos\beta}{\cos (\alpha+\beta )},\;$ whereas in $\Delta NYZ',$ $YZ'=\displaystyle\frac{a\cos\beta}{\sin\alpha}.$ Since $X'Y=YZ',$ we find the relation between $a\;$ and $b:$

$\displaystyle\frac{b\cos\beta}{\cos (\alpha+\beta )}=\frac{a\cos\beta}{\sin\alpha},$ or $b=\displaystyle\frac{a\cos(\alpha+\beta) }{\sin\alpha}.$

It follows that

$\displaystyle YZ=b\frac{\sin\beta}{\cos (\alpha+\beta)}=\frac{a\cos(\alpha+\beta) }{\sin\alpha}\cdot\frac{\sin\beta}{\cos (\alpha+\beta)}=\frac{a\sin\beta}{\sin\alpha}=XY,$

as required.

Proof 2

This proof is by Grégoire Nicollier and is one of the series of spectral proofs. It is directly based on his solution to Thébault's first problem which we reproduce first.

Let $q=(1,\,i,\,-1,\,-i)$ be the positively oriented unit square of the complex plane. Any nontrivial parallelogram $Q$ centered at the origin of the complex plane can be expressed up to a spiral similarity as $Q=q+b\bar q$ for some $b=x+iy\;$ or $Q=\bar q$. We suppose $Q=q+b\bar q$. Let $T(Q)$ be the quadrilateral obtained by erecting isosceles right-angled right-hand ears on the sides of $Q$. The transformation $T$ is linear and deletes $\bar q$: thus $T(Q)=T(q+b\bar q)=T(q)=\sqrt2e^{i\pi/4}q\;$ is a square.

Now, for Dao's extension.

An easy computation shows that the line through the vertices $i-ib$ and $1+b$ of $Q$ and the diagonal $t(1-i)$ of $T(Q)$ concur for $t=\left(x^2+ y^2-1\right)/(2x)$, as do the line through the vertices $-i+ib$ and $1+b$ of $Q$ and the diagonal $t(1+i)$ of $T(Q)$.


The problem has been posted by Dao Thanh Oai at the CutTheKnotMath facebook page.

Related material

Thébault's Problems

  • Thébault's Problem I
  • Thébault's Problem II
  • Thébault's Problem III
  • Y. Sawayama's Lemma
  • Jack D'Aurizio Proof of Sawayama's Lemma
  • Y. Sawayama's Theorem
  • Thébault's Problem III, Proof (J.-L. Ayme)
  • Circles Tangent to Circumcircle
  • Thébault's Problem IV
  • A Property of Right Trapezoids
  • A Lemma on the Road to Sawayama
  • Excircles Variant of Thébault's Problem III
  • In the Spirit of Thebault I
  • |Contact| |Front page| |Contents| |Geometry|

    Copyright © 1996-2018 Alexander Bogomolny