Cut the knot: learn to enjoy mathematics
A math books store at a unique math study site. Learn to enjoy mathematics.
Google
Web CTK
Try our no ads browsing

Sites for teachers
Sites for parents
Terms of use
Awards

Interactive Activities
CTK Exchange
CTK Wiki Math
CTK Insights - a blog

Games & Puzzles
What Is What
Arithmetic/Algebra
Geometry
Probability
Outline Mathematics
Make an Identity
Book Reviews
Stories for Young
Eye Opener
Analog Gadgets
Inventor's Paradox
Did you know?...
Proofs
Math as Language
Things Impossible
Visual Illusions
My Logo
Math Poll
Cut The Knot!
MSET99 Talk
Other Math sites
Front Page
Movie shortcuts
Personal info
Privacy Policy

Guest book
News sites

Recommend this site

Games to relax

Tutor Match Tutoring and Homework Help

Sites for teachers
Sites for parents

Education & Parenting

Manifesto: what CTK is about Buying a book is a commitment to learning Table of content Try our no ads browsing Things you can find on CTK Chronology of updates Email to Cut The Knot Recommend this page

The SSA

The acronym SSA (side-side-angle) refers to the criterion of congruence of two triangles: if two sides and an angle not include between them are respectively equal to two sides and an angle of the other then the two triangles are equal. (It is of course assumed that the equal angles at hand are adjacent to a pair of equal sides.)

Thus assume that in triangles ABC and A'B'C',

  AB = A'B', AC = A'C' and C = C'.

Let's show that then BC = B'C'. The SSS will then imply that ΔABC = ΔA'B'C'.

Proof

 

Let's place ΔA'B'C' on ΔABC so that side A'B' will coincide with AB. Let C'' will be the new position of point C'. Connect C and C''. There are two possibilities: either CC'' crosses line AB inside or outside the segment AB. In any event, Δ ACC'' is isosceles, since AC = A'C'. Consequently

  ACC'' = AC''C.

Since C = C'' we find, after subtracting equal angles from equal angles, that also

  BCC'' = BC''C.

Whereform ΔCBC'' is isosceles. Its sides are equal: BC = BC'' and, by SSS, ΔABC = ΔABC''. It then follows that ΔABC = ΔA'B'C'.

How's that? Is everything OK? Let's discuss this.

Copyright © 1996-2008 Alexander Bogomolny

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Discussion

Certainly there must be a mistake somewhere in the proof; for, as every one knows, the SSA is not a valid criteria for the equality of two triangles. The diagram is very much like that in Philo's proof of the SSS. And if we compare, it becomes obvious that, in our "proof" of SSA, one case is missing. Indeed, what happens if CC'' passes through B? Thinking of SSS, the effect is insignificant, but, for SSA, it makes all the difference:

 

Clearly, in the depicted configuration our reasoning fails.

References

  1. A. I. Fetisov, Ya. S. Dubnov, Proof in Geometry: With "Mistakes in Geometric Proofs", Dover, (December 25) 2006

Copyright © 1996-2008 Alexander Bogomolny

30864242Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape


Search:
Keywords:



Latest on CTK Exchange
try this puzzle ?/?? + ?/?? + ?/? ...
Posted by albert1950
5 messages
12:40 PM, Nov-18-08

Help me find Hisashi ABE, Pythago ...
Posted by likesmath
2 messages
11:11 AM, Oct-06-08

Bearing problem
Posted by Liliya
3 messages
11:32 AM, Nov-27-08

What is the smallest rational sqr ...
Posted by MinusOne
4 messages
04:32 PM, Nov-27-08

Three Concurrent Circles
Posted by billmillar
2 messages
12:26 PM, Oct-28-08

A geometry problem from N.A. Court
Posted by tvarhegyi
7 messages
11:48 AM, Nov-27-08

Error in Fractal Curves and Dimen ...
Posted by miguemate22
1 messages
08:51 AM, Nov-16-08