CTK Exchange Front Page Movie shortcuts Personal info Awards Reciprocal links Terms of use Privacy Policy Cut The Knot! MSET99 Talk Games & Puzzles Arithmetic/Algebra Geometry Probability Eye Opener Analog Gadgets Inventor's Paradox Did you know?... Proofs Math as Language Things Impossible My Logo Math Poll Other Math sit's Guest book News sit's Recommend this site
|Store|

CTK Exchange

 Subject: "Lewis Carroll's Pillow Problem" Previous Topic | Next Topic
 Conferences The CTK Exchange Guest book Topic #363 Printer-friendly copy     Email this topic to a friend Reading Topic #363
guest
Jul-05-04, 05:03 PM (EST)

"Lewis Carroll's Pillow Problem"

 Carroll's Pillow Problem--see the Probability problems--says that we know a bag contains one counter, and it is either black or white. The solution presumes that the bag is equally likely to contain a black counter or a white counter, although neither Carroll nor Bogomolny makes that clear. It would be helpful to make that point in the statement of the problem. Otherwise, the answer cannot be determined from the statement of the problem. This is just a particular instance of a more general problem. Suppose that the first counter is drawn at random from another bag containing d counters, n of which are white and d-n of which are black. Without revealing its color, this first counter is placed in a second, empty bag. Then a white counter is added to this bag. Now you draw a counter from this second bag and it turns out to be white. What is the probability that the remaining counter is white? The general answer is 2n/(n+d). I.e., if n=1 and d=2, the answer is 2/3, as given. But we can also determine the probability if n=1 and d=4 (2/5); if n=3 and d=4 (6/7); or if n=5 and d=18 (10/23).

alexb
Charter Member
1298 posts
Jul-07-04, 11:24 AM (EST)

1. "RE: Lewis Carroll's Pillow Problem"
In response to message #0

 Thank you. I have inserted your message as a footnote to the Carroll's page.