Go back to previous page
Forum URL: http://www.cut-the-knot.org/cgi-bin/dcforum/forumctk.cgi
Forum Name: This and that
Topic ID: 62
Message ID: 3
#3, RE: x^2 y^n = z^(2n)
Posted by alexb on Jan-01-01 at 01:23 AM
In response to message #2
Boa Ben-David wrote:
>
> If you "can't say anything about
> it" what does that mean?

That I know nothing about it. Just outside my interests and
expertise, if any.

> How do I pick the right people
> from within a thread, without getting
> entangled with non-proper people?

I do not know. May there be a special discussion group with focus
on number theory?

> The original saying is: "vedai
> lechachima birmiza"
>
> Assuming you know Hebrew,

I am an Israeli from 1974.

> your quote, change the meaning of the saying.
> I am not sure even if it's grammar is correct.

I am sure that given time I'll be able to point you to several
pages in Talmud where the saying appears just as "vedai lhaham."

I do not know where the original saying comes from.

> > is just an extended period
> > which a haham should not need.
> Ah, you got the saying wrong.

Well. I do not think so.

> > To say that the
> > above background is a hint to
> > a deeper meaning is to deny that it's
> > addressed to a haham.

> It doesn't say anything on any background.
> The saying just say that for a wise guy, a hint is enough.
> Obviously, the saying is not addressed to the wise.

The saying is addressed to a reader. As I said, it often
appears in talmud in the short version. It says nothing
of the background, but just terminates some words of wisdom.

You may want to check this with a rabbi in your neighborhood.

All the best,
Alexander Bogomolny