Birds on a Wire
By Moshe Eliner
Let's pass through all birds, starting, say, from the left, stopping at every fourth bird. I'll call this segments 4b. Notice a delicate point:
Denote the shortest connecting segments sc (i.e. yellow lines). Each 4b has 3 inner connecting segments (average 2).
Since:
the states of sc=1 and sc=3 force inner point positions on the neighboring 4b's.
on a uniform wire birds tend to have unfiorm distribution, hence inner point positions cannot be predefined.
so there cannot be sc=1 or 3 more than average. This implies that each 4b has on average sc=2.
Now it's enough to calulate the density when sc=2:
There are 3 possible sc=2's , but since one can rearrange segments inside the 4b, all have the same density, let's choose one of them, e.g., the one with two shortest at first:
Integrate ydxdy:
y=1/2..2/3, x=2y-1..1-y
y=0..1/2, x=0..y.
This yields 7/108, but since the total integration area is 1/6, the result density is: 7/18.
Geometric Probability
- Geometric Probabilities
- Are Most Triangles Obtuse?
- Barycentric Coordinates and Geometric Probability
- Bertrand's Paradox
- Birds On a Wire (Problem and Interactive Simulation)
- Birds on a Wire: Solution by Nathan Bowler
- Birds on a Wire. Solution by Mark Huber
- Birds on a Wire: a probabilistic simulation. Solution by Moshe Eliner
- Birds on a Wire. Solution by Stuart Anderson
- Buffon's Noodle Simulation
- Averaging Raindrops - an exercise in geometric probability
- Rectangle on a Chessboard: an Introduction
- Marking And Breaking Sticks
- Random Points on a Segment
|Contact| |Front page| |Contents| |Probability| |Up| |Store|
Copyright © 1996-2015 Alexander Bogomolny
| 49551885 |

